Trick-or-Treat!
We opted out of our church’s Reformation Day party this year. To my knowledge, this is only the second year our church has held one, and interestingly it is not really advertised other than bulletin inserts for about a month before the date. I appreciate the love of the adults planning the party–they adore the children in our church and want them to have a good time. But I have to ask, what is the purpose of a Reformation Day party? And how does that mesh with a missional church? And does it place unnecessary pressure upon the children (and adult and teen helpers) to give up an activity that they might otherwise participate in, and that might provide opportunities to meet neighbors?
Our family has gone through a personal transformation in our view of Halloween. You can read about it here, but we have gone from hiding in our house, pretending Halloween didn’t exist, to attending church festivals, to trick-or-treating. We have looked forward to trick-or-treating this year. When else can you wander the neighborhood, knock on doors, and chat with the neighbors without appearing odd or too forward? When else do neighbors pour into the streets, knocking on your door, and poking their heads in to introduce themselves? I can’t think of another time!
Some people may live in less-than-friendly neighborhoods, and I know that would present a challenge. But in the context of being part of a church that claims that it wants to reach out to our neighbors and friends, and ultimately to the city, some creativity may be needed. And in my opinion, that creativity does not come in the form of a Reformation Day party that is advertised only within the doors of the church. That is called insulating yourself against the neighbors and whatever you view as the evils of Halloween. If your neighborhood is not trick-or-treater friendly, perhaps you need to find a few neighbors and join forces to have some games and a bouncy contraption in the front yard. Or invite some neighbors over for a dress-up party! Or try to find a few houses with the lights on, knock on their doors, and then go to a nearby neighborhood.
I realize that some churches have a huge outreach-oriented party, and that is great! Some churches in our town do as well. It might be interesting to take a poll and see how many of the families that attend are from your own church, and how many are from outside of the church community. If you find that your church is not truly reaching out to others, and if it is your desire to meet, get to know, and ultimately reach out to your neighbors, then I suggest showing yourself to be friendly and interested in them. And what better time to begin that than on a holiday where your visit is welcome?
Here is my trick-or-treating gang:
DS9 and two friends went as the Blue Man Group:

And then DD5 and her daddy went as the Princess Bride and the Dread Pirate Roberts:

A great time (and buckets of candy) was had by all!
November 1st, 2007 at 7:17 am
I think a Reformation Day party is a great idea for celebrating the Reformation and having some good old church fellowship. You can be a missional church and still also emphasize inreach too. But it shouldn’t be a replacement for Halloween stuff… our old church had the celebration on a different night than Halloween.
November 1st, 2007 at 7:26 am
Inconceiveable!
Actually, my husband and I have had a similar discussion about the purpose of Reformation Day. We were relieved to discover that families in our new church celebrate Halloween by trick-or-treating in their neighborhoods and decorating with pumpkins and cheery (not super-scary) decorations. We also like to celebrate Halloween because it announces to the world that we (Christians) are not afraid of the powers and principalities– Christ is Lord over all, even Halloween. He has conquered, He has risen! Why shouldn’t we enjoy it?!
And Reformation Day celebrations aren’t bad, but I wonder what is the real purpose? Why honor particular saints (Luther, etc.) instead of just celebrating All Saints’ Day on Nov. 1st and honoring all those who have come before who glorify Christ?
November 1st, 2007 at 2:29 pm
Marcy,
I had that thought exactly! If we’re going to do a fall festival or Reformation Day party or whatever, why not do it on a different night? I think the reason so many don’t is because they are trying to have an alternative to trick or treating. Or they just haven’t thought it through. Frankly, calling it a “Reformation Day party” and having it on Halloween instead of trick-or-treating looks kinda silly to the “world.” We’re really just having a Halloween party and not inviting other people. And telling our kids to dress like Bible characters. I know, I know–both on the 31st and all. But come on. Like Allison said, why are we picking only a few saints to glorify? Because we’re trying to find an excuse to not celebrate Halloween….